Last Updated: November 02, 2000
Printer-friendly version
RESTON, Va. George Bush and Al Gore have broken with a long-standing tradition
among presidential candidates of providing their campaign positions on government
openness and public information.
Neither the Gore nor Bush campaigns responded to
repeated requests by the American Society of Newspaper Editors for their stances
on such issues as access to government information, the public's right to know,
privacy rights and plans for press conferences if elected president.
The society, which represents about 900 of the nation's
top newspaper editors, was sharply critical of the candidates and raised questions
about what this says about how Gore and Bush view these issues.
"Citizens have a right to know how their government
operates,'' said ASNE president Richard Oppel. "We wish Vice President
Gore and Gov. Bush would have taken the time to lay out their thinking on access
to information and the workings of government. We hope their decision does not
reflect negatively on their views about open government."
Anders Gyllenhaal, chair of ASNE's Freedom of Information
Committee, which watches over these issues for the society, said the candidates'
positions are particularly important now that digital technology is changing
the way information is made available.
"If ever there was a time that candidates ought
to be talking about how much information should be getting to the public and
what the government's role should be, this is that year,'' Gyllenhaal said.
It has been a tradition for ASNE to request the candidates'
positions and outline them in articles and releases so the public could compare
their stances. This is the first time in at least 20 years that the presidential
candidates have failed to respond.
The Gore and Bush campaigns were initially queried
five months ago on a half dozen issues involving public access, enforcement
of the Freedom of Information Act that governs the release of pubic information,
personal privacy, the regulation of records on the Internet and government handling
of electronic records.
For many decades, the society has been a leading
advocate of public access to information and has monitored government regulations
of information and creation of new information laws. The organization, for instance,
is currently pushing for the veto of legislation pending before President Clinton
that would, among other things, make it a crime for government officials to
release certain classified information.
Oppel referred to that legislation, which ASNE considers
duplicative and poorly drawn, in pointing out the importance of presidential
candidates making their positions known.
"In the face of growing efforts by Congress
to choke off the flow of leaks from the U.S. government, ASNE finds it disappointing
that neither major presidential candidate has chosen to respond to our questions
about their views on freedom of information. Even this week, press organizations
have been working to secure a veto of a bill sought by the Central Intelligence
Agency to penalize people who leak 'classified information' — when it is so
easy for agencies to designate information as classified.