How well do U.S. newspapers cover the world?
Published: December 21, 1999
Last Updated: January 10, 2000
Printer-friendly version
|
A review of international news coverage in 10
randomly selected small-to-medium newspapers found that the newspapers
ran just over seven stories a day, with the larger papers in the sampling
averaging nearly 10 stories a day. For all the papers, at least half of
all international stories were “briefs.”
The 10 papers’ A-sections showed an average ratio
of 82 percent domestic news and 18 percent international. For the large
papers in the sampling, an average of nearly 24 percent of the A section
was composed of international news, 18 percent in the mid-size papers,
and 15 percent in the general news sections of the smaller papers.
In a four-week period the AP ran 1,230 international
news items from 119 countries, but 70 percent of the file came from 20
countries. Approximately 85 percent of the AP international file was “episodic”
(spot or event) coverage, while the remaining 15 percent was “thematic”
(features, analysis, etc.).
The developed world got more attention than the
developing countries from all the news organizations studied, but newspapers
gave slightly more coverage to Africa than the AP did (7.8 percent compared
to 6.7 percent). England seemed particularly newsworthy during the month
studied, although there was little hard news, with heavy interest in the
royal family.
How the survey was done
In the summer of 1998, President Clinton made
headlines with his nine-day trip to China, political violence occurred
in Nigeria and Northern Ireland, a tsunami devastated Papua New Guinea,
Russia buried its last czar, and the troubled economies of Russia and Japan
were always in the news.
ASNE commissioned Beverly Horvit, a doctoral candidate
at the University of Missouri School of Journalism, Columbia, to review
international news coverage in a random sampling of 10 daily newspapers.
The study was funded by Knight Ridder.
Horvit analyzed The Associated Press file (during
the a.m. cycle) and coverage in the 10 newspapers from June 29 to July
26, 1998.
The participating newspapers
were:
-
25,000 to 50,000 circulation: The Dothan (Ala.) Eagle;
Leader-Telegram, Eau Claire, Wis.; The News-Gazette, Champaign, Ill.; and
The Sun, Bremerton, Wash.
-
50,001 to 100,000 circulation: The Journal Gazette,
Fort Wayne, Ind.; Reno (Nev.) Gazette-Journal; and Quad-City Times, Davenport,
Iowa.
-
100,001 to 250,000 circulation: The Post and Courier,
Charleston, S.C.; The Providence (R.I.) Journal; and the Richmond (Va.)
Times-Dispatch.
Other survey highlights:
-
Nearly 60 percent of the international stories appeared
in the A section, and nearly a quarter of the stories ran in the sports
section — an unusually high proportion due to World Cup activity in France.
Less than 8 percent of the international news ran in the business section.
-
The 10 newspapers published a total of 2,025 international
stories — an average of 203 per paper during the month.
-
Newspapers showed a strong interest in wars and disasters,
running proportionately more stories of this nature than those filed by
the AP (nearly 20 percent for the papers, compared to 16 percent for the
AP).
-
Newspapers showed less interest in Latin America
than the AP (10 percent compared to 14 percent of the AP’s international
file).
-
Both the newspapers and the AP showed approximately
the same interest in international government and diplomatic news.
-
Larger papers reflected a significantly higher attention
to trend, feature and analysis stories than the smaller papers did (18
percent vs. 12 percent), and slightly higher than the AP (15 percent).
The larger papers did more staff-generated coverage,
averaging about two internationally related stories a day, while smaller
papers did fewer. Examples of stories covered by the newspapers themselves:
-
The Post and Courier, Charleston, S.C., wrote about
the director of a local arts festival trying to get permission from Chinese
authorities to produce a Chinese opera, and how the community showed hospitality
to an international ship crew stranded at the local port.
-
The Providence (R.I.) Journal reported on a study
that found immigrants to the United States are worth the investment, once
a week offered a full page catering to its Spanish-speaking readers, and
reported that 3,000 Liberians in Rhode Island could be deported as a result
of new immigration legislation.
-
The Richmond (Va.) Times-Dispatch sent a reporter
to Brazil to examine how that country’s tobacco industry was competing
with Virginia’s and reported that a local university planned to open a
branch in the Persian Gulf state of Qatar.
Among the smaller papers: the Quad-City Times ran
a profile of a Kenyan runner and a story about local families taking in
Russian orphans, and the Reno (Nev.) Gazette-Journal wrote about how local
businesses were affected by the U.S. trade deficit and the impact of Asia’s
financial crisis on international students in the community.
In addition, The Journal Gazette in Fort Wayne,
Ind., spotlighted an Indiana U.S. senator’s work on international relations
and foreign policy. The Sun of Bremerton, Wash., did a feature story about
the role fathers play when wives go abroad — to Bosnia, for example — on
a military tour.
The News-Gazette, Champaign, Ill., reported on
a former local basketball star being recruited for international competition
and police officers from Russia who came to the local university for training.
|
|