Flint–Worcester tornado outbreak sequence
An F4 tornado near Erie, Michigan. |
|
Date of tornado outbreak: | June 7–9, 1953 |
Duration1: | 3 days |
Maximum rated tornado2: | F5 tornado |
Tornadoes caused: | 46 |
Damages: | $2.56 billion (2006 USD) |
Fatalities: | 243 |
Areas affected: | Midwest & Northeast United States |
1Time from first tornado to last tornado |
This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. (March 2008) |
The Flint–Worcester Tornadoes were two tornadoes, one occurring in Flint, Michigan on June 8, 1953, the other in Worcester, Massachusetts on June 9, 1953. These tornadoes are among the deadliest in United States history and were caused by the same storm system that moved eastward across the nation. The tornadoes are also related together in the public mind because, for a brief period following the Worcester tornado, it was debated in the U.S. Congress whether recent atomic bomb testing in the upper atmosphere had caused the tornadoes. Congressman James E. Van Zandt (R-Penn.) was among several members of Congress who expressed their belief that the June 4th bomb testing created the tornadoes, which occurred far outside the traditional tornado alley. They demanded a response from the government. Meteorologists quickly dispelled such an assertion, and Congressman Van Zandt later retracted his statement.
The Flint-Worcester Tornadoes were the most infamous storms produced by a larger outbreak of severe weather that began in Nebraska, Iowa and Wisconsin, before moving across the Great Lakes states, and then into New York and New England. Other F3 and F4 tornadoes struck other locations in Massachusetts, Michigan, New Hampshire and Ohio.
Contents |
[edit] Confirmed tornadoes
Confirmed Total |
Confirmed F0 |
Confirmed F1 |
Confirmed F2 |
Confirmed F3 |
Confirmed F4 |
Confirmed F5 |
46 | 11 | 9 | 13 | 7 | 5 | 1 |
This chart shows the number of tornadoes spawned from the initial storm system.
[edit] June 7, 1953 event
List of confirmed tornadoes — June 7, 1953 | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Kansas | ||||||
F1 | E of Morland | Graham | 1900 | 0.1 miles (0.16 km) |
||
F2 | S of Hill City | Graham | 1900 | 0.1 miles (0.16 km) |
||
F0 | S of Edmond | Graham | 1900 | 10.9 miles (17.4 km) |
||
F0 | NE of Tampa to SW of Herington | Marion, Dickinson | 0445 | 12.6 miles (20.2 km) |
||
Colorado | ||||||
F1 | W of Julesburg | Sedgwick | 2000 | 0.1 miles (0.16 km) |
||
F1 | N of Julesburg | Sedgwick | 2000 | 0.1 miles (0.16 km) |
||
F0 | SW of Julesburg (1st tornado) | Sedgwick | 2200 | 0.1 miles (0.16 km) |
||
F0 | SW of Julesburg (2nd tornado) | Sedgwick | 2200 | 0.1 miles (0.16 km) |
||
F0 | NW of Julesburg | Sedgwick | 2200 | 0.1 miles (0.16 km) |
||
Nebraska | ||||||
F2 | NE of Mason City | Custer, Sherman, Valley | 2030 | 6.6 miles (10.6 km) |
Farm houses were destroyed and livestock were killed. Barns were leveled as well. | |
F2 | NW of Giltner | Hamilton | 2100 | 6.6 miles (10.6 km) |
Roofs were torn off homes. | |
F0 | S of Phillips | Hamilton | 2100 | 4.1 miles (6.6 km) |
||
F1 | NE of Rising City to NW of Linwood | Butler | 2100 | 22.7 miles (36.3 km) |
Barns were destroyed. | |
F4 | NW of Loup City to SW of Ord | Sherman, Valley | 2115 | 15 miles (24 km) |
11 deaths Homes were completely leveled and a car was thrown a quarter mile through the air. | |
F2 | E of Scotia to SW of Spalding | Greeley | 2200 | 20.1 miles (32.2 km) |
||
F2 | NE of Octavia | Butler | 2200 | 6.9 miles (11 km) |
||
F3 | NW of Albion | Boone | 2215 | 8 miles (12.8 km) |
A house was destroyed along with multiple barns. Paint was stripped from a tractor and livestock were killed. | |
F0 | SE of Upland | Franklin | 2230 | 9 miles (14.4 km) |
||
F1 | E of Macon | Franklin | 2300 | 15 miles (24 km) |
||
F2 | SW of Battle Creek to S of Pierce | Madison | 2300 | 16.6 miles (26.6 km) |
||
F2 | SW of Pierce to SW of Laurel | Pierce, Cedar | 2300 | 31 miles (49.6 km) |
Barns and outbuildings were destroyed. | |
F1 | N of Breslau | Pierce | 2310 | 8.2 miles (13.1 km) |
||
F0 | SW of Martinsburg | Dixon | 2340 | 1.5 miles (2.4 km) |
||
F2 | NW of Blair | Washington | 0045 | 4.1 miles (6.6 km) |
||
F0 | S of Hooper | Dodge | 0100 | 1 mile (1.6 km) |
Farm buildings and barns were destroyed. | |
South Dakota | ||||||
F0 | N of Mitchell | Davison | 2345 | 1.5 miles (2.4 km) |
||
Iowa | ||||||
F2 | NE of Westfield | Plymouth | 0015 | 11.3 miles (18.1 km) |
Barns were destroyed. | |
F2 | N of Ida Grove to E of Fenton | Ida, Sac, Pocahontas, Kossuth | 0130 | 49.2 miles (78.7 km) |
Barns were destroyed | |
F2 | N of Gowrie to SW of Olaf | Webster, Hamilton, Wright | 0300 | 49 miles (78.4 km) |
A church was lifted up and set down again. Barns were destroyed as well. | |
F3 | W of Pomeroy to SE of Bode | Calhoun, Pocahontas, Humboldt | 0315 | 30.7 miles (49.1 km) |
||
F2 | NE of Winterset to E of Walford | Madison, Warren, Polk, Jasper, Poweshiek, Iowa, Johnson | 0315 | 116 miles (185.6 km) |
Several barns were destroyed. | |
F1 | E of Boxholm | Boone, Hamilton | 0330 | 2.3 miles (3.7 km) |
||
Minnesota | ||||||
F1 | SE of Trimont to SE of Grogan | Martin, Watonwan | 0100 | 19.1 miles (30.6 km) |
||
Source: Tornado History Project - June 7, 1953 Storm Data |
[edit] June 8, 1953 event
List of confirmed tornadoes — June 8, 1953 | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Michigan | ||||||
F4 | NE of Temperance | Monroe | 2315 | 5.4 miles (8.6 km) |
4 deaths 15 houses destroyed and 14 more damaged. Trucks and cars were hurled through the air. | |
F3 | SW of Ann Arbor | Washtenaw | 0030 | 11.3 miles (18.1 km) |
1 death A large tree landed on one house. One house was destroyed along with three barns | |
F3 | W of Milford | Livingston, Oakland | 0030 | 9.1 miles (14.6 km) |
||
F3 | E of Sand Lake to N of Oscoda | Iosco | 0040 | 16.6 miles (26.6 km) |
4 deaths 5 vacation cabins leveled, and 6 others badly damaged. | |
F2 | S of Spruce | Alcona | 0108 | 1.8 miles (2.9 km) |
5 large barns were destroyed and livestock were killed. | |
F5 | N of Flushing to N of Columbiaville | Genesee, Lapeer | 0130 | 18.9 miles (30.2 km) |
116 deaths See section below. | |
F0 | SW of Caseville | Huron | 0300 | 0.1 miles (0.16 km) |
||
F4 | N of Kings Mill to N of Port Huron | Lapeer, St. Clair | 0330 | 33.8 miles (54.1 km) |
Two homes and several barns were blown away | |
Ohio | ||||||
F4 | N of Deshler to Cleveland | Henry, Wood, Sandusky, Erie, Lorain, Cuyahoga | 0000 | 118 miles (188.8 km) |
17 deaths Homes were swept away. May have been an F5. | |
Source: Tornado History Project - June 8, 1953 Storm Data |
[edit] June 9, 1953 event
List of confirmed tornadoes — June 9, 1953 | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Massachusetts | ||||||
F4 | W of Petersham to NE of Fayville | Worcester | 2025 | 46.0 miles (74.03 km) |
94 deaths See section below. | |
F3 | E of West Millbury to SE of Foxborough | Worcester, Norfolk, Bristol | 2130 | 28 miles (44.8 km) |
Cars and trucks were overturned and numerous trees were downed. Homes sustained roof and wall damage. | |
New Hampshire | ||||||
F3 | SW of Exeter | Rockingham | 2120 | 1.5 miles (2.4 km) |
15 homes and businesses had their roofs torn off. A country club lodge was destroyed. | |
F1 | W of South Berwick | Strafford | 2200 | 1 mile (1.6 km) |
||
Source: Tornado History Project - June 9, 1953 Storm Data |
[edit] Flint tornado
An F5 tornado hit Flint, Michigan on June 8, 1953.[1] The tornado moved east-northeast 2 miles (3.2 km) north of Flushing and devastated the north side of Flint and Beecher. The tornado first descended about 8:30 p.m. on a humid evening near a drive-in movie theater that was flickering to life at twilight time. Motorists in the drive-in began to flee in panic, creating many auto accidents on nearby roads. The tornado dissipated near Lapeer, Michigan. Nearly every home was destroyed on both sides of Coldwater Road. Multiple deaths were reported in 20 families, and it was reported that papers from Flint were deposited in Sarnia, Ontario, Canada, some sixty miles east of Flint. Large sections of neighborhoods were completely swept away, with only foundations left. Trees were debarked and vehicles were thrown and mangled. One hundred and sixteen were killed,[2] making it the tenth deadliest tornado in U.S. history.[3] The death toll was surpassed by the 2011 Joplin tornado.[4] It is also one of only three F5 tornadoes ever to hit in Michigan. Another F5 would hit in Hudsonville on April 3, 1956.
[edit] Worcester tornado
This unreferenced section requires citations to ensure verifiability. |
The storm system that created the Flint tornado moved eastward over southern Ontario and Lake Erie during the early morning hours of June 9. As radar was still primitive (or nonexistent) in 1953, inadequate severe weather predictions resulted: the Weather Bureau in Buffalo, New York merely predicted thunderstorms and said that "a tornado may occur." As early as 10 A.M., however, the Weather Bureau in Boston anticipated the likelihood of tornadic conditions that afternoon but feared the word "tornado" would strike panic in the public, and refrained from using it. Instead, as a compromise, they issued New England's first-ever severe thunderstorm watch. Several hours later and virtually without warning (to the public at least), a strong F4 tornado struck central Massachusetts in the late afternoon hours on June 9, 1953. The tornado descended over the Quabbin Reservoir in Petersham, Massachusetts at 4:25 P.M., and was witnessed by boaters on the reservoir - 3 funnels were seen at the beginning, with rapid dissipation of 1 of them. After brushing Petersham (occasionally with twin funnels several hundred feet apart), it tracked southeastwards and slammed into the rural towns of Barre and Rutland, followed by suburban Holden, before killing 60 in heavily populated northern Worcester. The towns of Shrewsbury and Westborough each suffered numerous fatalities. The tornado did its final destruction at the Fayville post office on Route 9 in Southborough, and dissipated nearby over the Sudbury Reservoir in the Framingham area, 84 minutes after it formed.
Ninety-four people were killed. A 95th fatality has recently been brought to light: a premature baby boy delivered in the hospital elevator to his traumatically injured mother - doctors tried keeping him alive but he succumbed a day and a half later.[citation needed]
Coincidentally, residents of central Massachusetts were coming home from work in the minutes before impact and picked up their evening newspapers to read the front-page headlines of the tornado that had just struck Flint, Michigan the previous evening. Some wondered if it was exactly the same tornado that was now bearing down on them.
State | Total | County | County total |
---|---|---|---|
Massachusetts | 94 | Worcester | 94 |
Michigan | 125 | Genesee | 116 |
Iosco | 4 | ||
Monroe | 4 | ||
Washtenaw | 1 | ||
Nebraska | 11 | Valley | 11 |
Ohio | 17 | Cuyahoga | 6 |
Erie | 2 | ||
Henry | 5 | ||
Lorain | 1 | ||
Wood | 3 | ||
Totals | 247 | ||
All deaths were tornado-related |
The massive Worcester tornado was on the ground for nearly an hour and a half. In that period it traveled 46 miles (74 km), reached 1-mile (1.6 km) in width and injured 1,300 people. Barre suffered the first 2 fatalities. The tornado then renewed its vigor in Rutland center with 2 more deaths, and widened to 1/2 mile in Holden, where 9 were killed outright (a 10th succumbed 2 days later), the worst-hit areas being Winthrop Oaks and Brentwood.
At 5:08 P.M., the tornado entered Worcester and grew to an unprecedented width of 1-mile (1.6 km). Damage was phenomenal in Worcester (second-largest city in Massachusetts) and in some areas equaled the worst damage in any U.S. tornado. Hardest-hit areas included Assumption College (building is now home to Quinsigamond Community College), where a priest and 2 nuns were killed. The main building's 3-foot (0.91 m)-thick brick walls were reduced by 3 floors, and the landmark tower lost 3 stories. The nearby Burncoat Hill neighborhood saw heavy devastation (especially on its western slope), but it was the Uncatena-Great Brook Valley neighborhoods to the east of Burncoat Hill that were utterly leveled, houses simply vanishing and debris swept clean from the sites. Forty people died in the Uncatena-Great Brook Valley areas alone. A 12-ton bus was picked up, rolled over several times and was thrown against the newly-constructed Curtis Apartments in Great Brook Valley, resulting in the deaths of 2 passengers. The Curtis Apartments blueprints were blown all the way to Duxbury (near Plymouth), 75 miles (121 km) away. Across Boylston St. from the Curtis Apartments, the Brookside Home Farm (a city-operated dairy facility and laundry) sustained total damage, with 6 men killed and the loss of its herd of 80 Holsteins. Houses and bodies were blown into Lake Quinsigamond. The 6 fatalities at Brookside were the most in any 1 particular building in the tornado.
The funnel maintained a 1-mile (1.6 km) width throughout much of Shrewsbury (12 killed), and was still doing maximum damage when it moved through downtown Westborough (5 deaths), where it began curving towards the northeast in its final leg. In the storm's final moments, 3 perished in the collapse of the Fayville Post Office in Southborough. Coincidentally, around the time it ended at 5:45 P.M., a tornado warning was issued, although by then it was too late. A separate F2/3 tornado also struck about the same time the warning was issued, in the nearby communities of Sutton, Northbridge, Mendon, Bellingham, Franklin, Wrentham and Mansfield in Massachusetts, injuring 17 persons. Another tornado did minor damage and caused several injuries in Fremont and Exeter in Rockingham County, New Hampshire; other smaller tornadoes occurred in Colrain, Massachusetts and Rollinsford, New Hampshire.
Baseball-size hail was reported in a score of communities affected by the Worcester supercell. Airborne debris was strewn eastward, reaching the Blue Hill Meteorological Observatory 35 mi (56 km) away, and even out over Massachusetts Bay and the Atlantic Ocean. The farthest documented distance of tornado debris was an item that blew from Holden to Eastham on Cape Cod, a distance of 110 miles (180 km). This is one of the greatest such instances in a U.S. tornado.
The Worcester Tornado was a milestone in many regards. Besides its enormous size and unusual geographic location, at the time it was the nation's costliest tornado in raw dollars. Its 1,300 injuries were the 3rd worst in U.S. history (until the 1979 Wichita Falls tornado bumped it to number 4, where it still stands). The tally of 10,000 homeless stood unchallenged for 26 years until the '79 Wichita Falls storm.
However, the Worcester Tornado's greatest effect on the nation was its being the principal catalyst for the Storm Prediction Center's reorganization on June 17, 1953, and subsequent implementation of a nationwide radar/storm spotter system. The results proved successful: since June 9, 1953, no single U.S. tornado had killed over 100 people until the Joplin, Missouri tornado of May 22, 2011.
The severity of this epic storm remained in dispute for a long period within the meteorological community. Official observations classified this tornado as F4, but damage was consistent with an F5 tornado in 5 of the affected towns (Rutland, Holden, Worcester, Shrewsbury and Westborough). As a result of this debate, the National Weather Service took an unprecedented step and convened a panel of weather experts during the spring of 2005 to study the latest evidence on the wind strength of the Worcester Tornado. The panel considered whether to raise its designation to F5, but decided during the summer of 2005 to keep the official rating as a strong F4. The reasoning for this was that the anchoring techniques used in many of the destroyed or vanished homes could never now be ascertained with certainty, and some of these structures (many of recent postwar construction) were possibly more vulnerable to high winds than older homes. Without a proper engineering qualification, it would be nearly impossible to determine with 100% accuracy which damage was F5 and which was F4, as appearances would be similar.
[edit] 1953 tornado season in perspective
The year 1953 saw some of the deadliest tornadoes in U.S. history, including the Waco Tornado that hit on May 11, the Flint tornado of June 8, and the Worcester tornado on June 9. These 3 storms were also unique in occurring within a 30-day period.
Other severe tornadoes of 1953 hit Warner Robins, Georgia in April, San Angelo, Texas in May (same day as Waco), Port Huron, Michigan also in May, Cleveland in June (same day as Flint), and Vicksburg, Mississippi in December.
[edit] See also
[edit] References
- Chittick, William F. (2003). The Worcester Tornado, June 9, 1953. Bristol, RI: Private Publication.
- Chittick, William F. (2005). What Is So Rare As A Day In June: The Worcester Tornado, June 9, 1953. Bristol, RI: Multimedia Presentation.
- O'Toole, John M. (1993). Tornado! 84 minutes, 94 lives. Worcester: Chandler House Press. ISBN 0-9636277-0-8
[edit] Notes
- ^ "Southeast Michigan Tornado Climatology". National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. http://www.crh.noaa.gov/dtx/1953beecher/torClimateIntroduction.php. Retrieved 2007-01-03.
- ^ "1953 Beecher Tornado". National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. http://www.crh.noaa.gov/dtx/1953beecher/. Retrieved 2007-01-03.
- ^ "The 25 Deadliest U.S. Tornadoes". National Weather Service Storm Prediction Center. http://www.spc.noaa.gov/faq/tornado/killers.html. Retrieved 24 May 2011.
- ^ "Joplin, Mo., single deadliest tornado since 1950". CBS News. http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2011/05/24/national/main20065604.shtml.
[edit] External links
- Full map of Flint-Worcester tornado outbreak Tornado History Project
- Video interview of tornado survivor (and nurse) who tended to injured
- Beecher Tornado - Flint Public Library Archive
- Beecher Tornado - Flint Journal Beecher Tornado Anniversary
- 1953 Worcester Tornado Slideshow - City of Worcester
- Worcester Telegram and Gazette site on Worcester tornado
- The Worcester Tornado of 1953
10 costliest US tornadoes | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Rank | Area affected | Date | Damage 1 | Adjusted Damage 2 |
1 | Joplin, Missouri | May 22, 2011 | 2800 | 2893 |
2 | Tuscaloosa, Alabama | April 27, 2011 | 2200 | 2273 |
3 | Oklahoma City Metro, Oklahoma | May 3, 1999 | 1000 | 1394 |
4 | Hackleburg, Alabama | April 27, 2011 | 1250 | 1291 |
5 | Wichita Falls, Texas | April 10, 1979 | 400 | 1280 |
6 | Omaha, Nebraska | May 6, 1975 | 250 | 1079 |
7 | Lubbock, Texas Tornado | May 11, 1970 | 135 | 808 |
8 | Topeka, Kansas Tornado | June 8, 1966 | 100 | 715 |
9 | Windsor Locks, Connecticut | October 3, 1979 | 200 | 640 |
10 | St. Louis-East St. Louis Tornado | May 27, 1896 | 12 | 550 |
Source: Brooks, Harold E.; C.A. Doswell (Feb 2001). "Normalized Damage from Major Tornadoes in the United States: 1890–1999". Weather and Forecasting (American Meteorological Society) 16 (1): 168-76. doi:10.1175/1520-0434(2001)016<0168:NDFMTI>2.0.CO;2. http://ams.allenpress.com/perlserv/?request=get-abstract&doi=10.1175%2F1520-0434(2001)016%3C0168%3ANDFMTI%3E2.0.CO%3B2. 3 |
||||
1. These are the unadjusted damage totals in millions of US dollars. 2. Raw damage totals adjusted for inflation, in millions of 2012 USD. 3. A search of NCDC Storm Data indicates no tornadoes between 1999 and 2010 have caused more than $250 million in damage. |