Stephen Carty

Stephen Carty

Agrees with the Tomatometer 76% of the time.

Publications:
Empire Magazine , Eye for Film , Flix Capacitor
Critics' Group:
Online Film Critics Society
Total Reviews:
171
Location:
Edinburgh, Scotland

Listing Of All Reviews & Articles

Showing 51 - 100 of 171
Rating T-Meter Title | Year Add Date
2.5/5 76% The Bay (2012) " While effective at making our skin crawl, this eco-themed frightener can't help but feel like an unremarkable footnote in a sub-genre which peaked years ago. Why now Baz?" — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 27, 2013
3/5 29% Broken City (2013) " It's fine if you're in the mood for a perfunctory Mark Wahlberg crime drama, but not nearly as smart, slick or subtle as it needs to be. More medium-toasted than hard-boiled. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 26, 2013
1.5/5 42% To The Wonder (2013) " Arguably Terrence Malick's most Malick-y film to date, at times To The Wonder feels like a Malick parody. Visually, it's absolutely stunning, but the 'story' is abstract even by his standards." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 23, 2013
3/5 94% The Sessions (2012) " While the sex sessions are frank, candid and populated by a constantly-naked Helen Hunt, it's far more warm and feelgood than you might be expecting. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 21, 2013
2.5/5 44% The Paperboy (2012) " Though not quite the trainwreck that its kicking at Cannes suggested, The Paperboy doesn't know what it wants to be. Still, anyone who likes the sight of Zac Efron in his pants will be in heaven. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 21, 2013
4/5 87% Arbitrage (2012) " A tightly-wound character thriller, Arbitrage keeps the tension simmering while showcasing a career best from Richard Gere. You don't need a degree in economics to watch." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 21, 2013
3/5 68% Stoker (2013) " Visually, the film is compelling and precise, but the story isn't able to keep us interested throughout." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 19, 2013
3.5/5 87% Frankenweenie (2012) " Something of a return to form for Tim Burton, Frankenweenie plays like a Greatest Hits by way of his early work." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 19, 2013
4/5 24% Medicine Man (1992) " An underrated character drama which occasionally slips into thriller mode, Medicine Man is an engaging piece of forgotten '90s cinema. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 17, 2013
3/5 52% This is 40 (2012) " While insightful when it comes to relationships and the differences between men and women, This Is 40 is too long and not particularly funny. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 15, 2013
4/5 77% Populaire (2013) " Far more energetic, vibrant and exciting than a subtitled French film about typing in the late '50s has any right to be, Populaire is hugely charming and genuinely funny." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 15, 2013
2/5 14% A Good Day To Die Hard (2013) " Pretty much on a par with Die Hard 4.0, the poorly-titled A Good Day To Die Hard is essentially four big set pieces and a lot of explosions. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 14, 2013
3/5 66% Cloud Atlas (2012) " Wrestling such a sprawling tapestry onto the screen is a grand accomplishment in itself, but the end result doesn't pack that much punch." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 13, 2013
3.5/5 81% Warm Bodies (2013) " It sounds utterly ridiculous in theory, but Warm Bodies is warm, sweet and charming. And, more importantly, it's no po-faced, sullen-Cullen mope-fest. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 8, 2013
2.5 / 5 81% Live Free or Die Hard (2007) " Die Hard 4.0 is a solid actioner and not the franchise embarrassment that many feared it would be. However, it's also silly and preposterous, and rarely feels like a Die Hard movie." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 7, 2013
3/5 63% Hitchcock (2012) " Hitchcock aims to tell the "untold story", but also functions as Alfred Hitchcock For Beginners. It's more slight and glossy than penetrating or definitive, but the subject matter is interesting enough." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 7, 2013
3/5 86% Wreck-it Ralph (2012) " Wreck-It Ralph has a promising setup and the opening will strike a chord with gamers of a certain age, but it never recovers from a dull midsection which gradually squanders a great idea." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 5, 2013
3.5/5 52% Die Hard 3: With a Vengeance (1995) " Though still a far cry from the peerless original, Die Hard With A Vengeance is a big improvement over the second. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 2, 2013
2.5/5 67% Die Hard 2 (1990) " While the original redefined the action genre with a suspenseful game of cat-and-mouse, this poorly-named sequel (Die Harder? Oh come on) is more of a standard actioner. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 1, 2013
3/5 47% Bullet to the Head (2013) " There's no chemistry between Stallone and Kang, but Sly elevates some clunky dialogue with a rumbling voice worthy of Nick Nolte. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Feb 1, 2013
4.5/5 92% Die Hard (1988) " Undoubtedly, it's dated in some respects, but as a pure actioner Die Hard remains timeless. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 31, 2013
1.5/5 67% Death Proof (2007) " Overly talky and dialogue heavy even by QT's standards, Death Proof takes forever to get going and then re-starts again when it does." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 24, 2013
3/5 96% Monsters, Inc. (2001) " While nippers will love the colourful creatures and their slapstick antics, grown-ups will find less humour and layers than in the likes of Toy Story, meaning less overall appeal as a result. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 23, 2013
2.5/5 89% Lincoln (2012) " While Lincoln is high-minded and classy, it plays like a dry history lesson, despite a typically immaculate turn from Daniel Day-Lewis. In short, we have the definitive performance of Abraham Lincoln, but not the definitive movie." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 22, 2013
3/5 60% The Last Stand (2013) " More of a solid-to-middling comeback than a triumphant one, The Last Stand starts flat before exploding into an entertaining last third. It's not great, but it's good to see Arnold back so let's not give him too much of a raw deal." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 22, 2013
4.5/5 79% Following (1999) " The scale is a million Gotham miles from the likes of, say, the Dark Knight trilogy or Inception, but yet, it's still very much a Christopher Nolan film. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 21, 2013
4/5 88% Fond Kiss..., Ae, (Just a Kiss) (2004) " It's not as strong as either My Name Is Joe or Sweet Sixteen, but Loach and Laverty deserve credit for carving out a thoughtful study of intolerance." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 19, 2013
3/5 74% Sunshine (2007) " Sunshine has a great sci-fi set-up, but sadly it never lives up to it and rarely proving as gripping as you'd like:" — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 19, 2013
3/5 88% Django Unchained (2012) " A close cousin of sorts to Inglourious Basterds, Django Unchained sees great set pieces, flashes of brilliance and another great performance by Christoph Waltz undermined by indulgent tendencies." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 17, 2013
4/5 93% Zero Dark Thirty (2013) " It's particularly comparable to Zodiac, while there are also obvious parallels to Homeland, and a riveting, Call Of Duty-type finale." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 15, 2013
2/5 20% The Wee Man () " Compston does his best, but the various power-plays and shifting alliances feel like musical chairs, while Burgis' attempts to make Ferris sympathetic are under-cooked and generic. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 15, 2013
2.5/5 77% Planet Terror (Grindhouse Presents: Robert Rodriguez's Planet Terror) (2007) " While it's initially fun to see Rodriguez recreate a knowingly schlocky B-movie, it soon runs out of steam and the joke wears a little thin. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 11, 2013
4/5 91% The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974) " Though certain aspects of the film don't hold up that well, Tobe Hooper's seminal horror remains a hugely disturbing experience." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 10, 2013
3/5 38% Hyde Park on Hudson (2012) " This 30's-set country house period drama will prove too dull for some (imagine Downtown Abbey without the soapy antics), but it works as a showcase for Murray to demonstrate some impressive range. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 9, 2013
2.5/5 32% Gangster Squad (2013) " Noticeably impatient, Gangster Squad often feels like it's in a hurry to get to the next scene, leaving important details and developments to be rushed through as though there was a time limit on non-action scenes. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 9, 2013
3.5/5 100% The Navigators (2003) " Ken Loach instils his usual trademarks - effortless realism, naturalistic dialogue, working class struggles - but the end result is more solid Loach than it is vintage." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 5, 2013
3/5 88% Inglourious Basterds (2009) " Representative of Quentin Tarantino as a whole, Inglourious Basterds demonstrates his strengths and weaknesses. In short, there are some great scenes, but also too much self-indulgence." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 4, 2013
4/5 97% The Hurt Locker (2009) " Though the slow-building occasionally drags, for the most part The Hurt Locker is a masterclass in how to build tension. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 4, 2013
2.5/5 69% Les Misérables (2012) " The actors singing live on set gives the performances a raw authenticity, but the substantial running time is punishing. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Jan 4, 2013
3/5 81% The Impossible (2012) " While The Impossible is undoubtedly the sort of picture that many will be impressed by, there's not much to it." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 30, 2012
4/5 68% Point Break (1991) " Part beach bromance, part cult actioner, part search for meaning, it's an adrenalin-pumping thrill ride with so much macho testosterone that it's hard to imagine many male directors with bigger balls than Kathryn Bigelow. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 28, 2012
3/5 —— The Girl (2012) " Despite capturing the contradictory nature of Hitchcock's personality, it also feels a tad one-note." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 28, 2012
3/5 94% Amour (2012) " Amour is just as likely to put someone to sleep as it is to win high-brow praise. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 27, 2012
4/5 72% Grabbers (2013) " Grabbers doesn't reinvent the horror wheel, but it rises above such quibbles with lovely coastal charm and lots of feck-fuelled laughs. " — Empire Magazine
Posted Dec 27, 2012
3/5 91% Safety Not Guaranteed (2012) " Safety Not Guaranteed has the same sort of sweet, oddball sadness which permeated Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind, but the variety bag of ingredients doesn't really add up to much. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 27, 2012
4.5/5 100% Raining Stones (1993) " Boasting all the gritty hallmarks we've come to expect from Ken Loach (working class struggles, unparalleled authenticity, accents that might require subtitles), Raining Stones is another mini masterpiece from the master of social realism." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 26, 2012
3/5 86% Carla's Song (1998) " A film of two contrasting halves, Carla's Song isn't among Ken Loach's best work." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 26, 2012
5/5 94% The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003) " Rousing, satisfying and awe-inspiring, The Return Of The King provides a worthy conclusion to what is both an incredible cinematic achievement and the finest fantasy filmmaking ever to grace our screens. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 23, 2012
5/5 96% The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (2002) " Less a sequel to The Fellowship Of The Ring than it is a seamless continuation, The Two Towers is another immersive marriage of stirring storytelling and stunning spectacle." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 23, 2012
4/5 62% Jack Reacher (2012) " Starting strong and staying that way throughout, Jack Reacher is a superior action thriller with hard edges and more humour than you're probably expecting. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 21, 2012
4.5/5 94% The Damned United (2009) " You might not call it the best film ever made about British football, but it's definitely in the top one." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 21, 2012
3.5/5 95% Escape from Alcatraz (1979) " Clint Eastwood is essentially playing Clint Eastwood, but then that's what we watch him for. There's not nearly enough Patrick McGoohan, though." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 20, 2012
3/5 48% The Way of the Gun (2000) " A post-modern blend of Quentin Tarantino and Butch Cassidy And The Sundance Kid, The Way Of The Gun sees talky, amoral criminals yakking out anecdotal stories in between loud, Western-styled gun fights." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 20, 2012
4/5 80% Young Adult (2011) " With Juno, Jason Reitman and Diablo Cody gifted us a sunny gem where self-aware teens spoke like adults, but with Young Adult they give us a darker piece where an unaware, self-deceptive 'adult' sees the world like a teen. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 19, 2012
2.5/5 84% Sightseers (2013) " Essentially a one-joke film, your ability to enjoy Sightseers will depend on how funny you find the idea of a pair of humdrum Brummies turning a damp caravan holiday into a bloody killing spree." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 18, 2012
3/5 62% Valkyrie (2008) " While capable of generating suspense and tension, Valkyrie is sadly less than the sum of its parts." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 17, 2012
5/5 92% The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001) " Stunning in every department, The Fellowship Of The Ring remains a stirring, spectacular achievement. The fantasy film to rule them all." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 16, 2012
3/5 71% Blue Steel (1990) " There are shades of the tense, muscular action for which the director is now known, but often it all feels overly drawn-out and stylised, as the slow-mo button gets a fair old work out." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 16, 2012
1.5/5 12% Alex Cross (2012) " Instead of the thinky, psychological crime thriller it should have been, Rob Cohen's Alex Cross offers a lifeless and generic actioner. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 11, 2012
3/5 65% The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012) " While it's great to be back on Middle Earth, there's a nagging sense throughout that the magic is gone and that we've been here (and back again) before. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 11, 2012
3.5/5 70% The Hunter (2012) " Part character piece, part family drama and part survivalist thriller, it's most successful when Dafoe is patiently stalking through the woodland, as his craggy presence and the moody cinematography are enough to hold our interest." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 10, 2012
4/5 97% Psycho (1960) " The shower sequence, the shrieking score, Anthony Perkins, that twist ending... Psycho remains a stone-cold classic." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 8, 2012
4.5/5 88% Life of Pi (2012) " A spiritual, magical-realist blend of Slumdog Millionaire and Cast Away, Life Of Pi is one of the year's most striking films. Another triumph for Ang Lee." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 7, 2012
3/5 81% Pitch Perfect (2012) " You'd be perfectly within your rights to go in expecting Glee: The Movie, but Pitch Perfect is closer in tone to Mean Girls and surprisingly funny." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Dec 6, 2012
4.5/5 90% The Shining (1980) " A feeling of deep-rooted evil runs through every frame in mesmerising fashion. Hell, even the dizzyingly-patterned carpets are somewhat hypnotic." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 29, 2012
3/5 52% Trouble with the Curve (2012) " As a sports flick-come-family drama, Trouble With The Curve is undoubtedly by-the-numbers. But if you can get past the familiarity and predictability, it's perfectly watchable and worth seeing for Clint." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 28, 2012
2.5/5 63% Anna Karenina (2012) " While the framing device and Wright's style differentiates this slightly from the usual mix of corsets, longing looks and stilted period dialogue, we're still left with a mix of corsets, longing looks and stilted period dialogue. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 27, 2012
2/5 48% The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 2 (2012) " Haters will hate, Twi-hards will love hard and the objective viewer will find another flawed spectacle which, while not as without merit as some would argue, is still easy to pick apart." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 25, 2012
3/5 48% Snow White and the Huntsman (2012) " Despite looking great and providing a dark antidote to the silly panto-antics of Mirror Mirror, Snow White And The Huntsman is frustratingly unremarkable in terms of storytelling." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 25, 2012
4.5/5 93% The Hunt (2013) " Never less than riveting, it isn't just Vinterberg's best film in years, but one of most affecting films of the year, full stop." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 24, 2012
2.5/5 82% Seven Psychopaths (2012) " While most of the movie's deficiencies could be explained away as meta, you're always aware that you're watching a movie." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 24, 2012
3.5/5 85% End of Watch (2012) " The crime plotting is a touch familiar, but the buddy dynamic is hugely convincing and watchable." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 19, 2012
4/5 95% Don't Look Now (1973) " Though it seems like nothing much is happening for most of the running time, you always have the feeling that it's all building towards something shattering. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 15, 2012
1.5/5 33% Nativity 2 () " It might seem somewhat Scrooge-y to criticise a festive kids film, but after enduring Nativity 2: Danger In The Manger, it's difficult to find positive things to say. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 14, 2012
3/5 85% The Master (2012) " Another challenging, impeccably crafted and purposefully uncomfortable effort which will delight arthouse buffs and bore mainstream viewers in equal measure, The Master isn't for everyone." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 13, 2012
4/5 92% Silver Linings Playbook (2012) " In line with Russell's early work, it's rough-edged and has the look of an indie movie, but like his last picture, The Fighter, it functions as a winsome crowd-pleaser with solid Oscar potential." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 10, 2012
2/5 0% Dark Tide (2012) " Despite the appeal of Halle Berry swimming with sharks in a bikini, you can see why Dark Tide went straight to DVD." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 9, 2012
2.5/5 79% The Deep Blue Sea (2012) " While the soft focus cinematography and performances are excellent, we're kept at such a distance that it's hard to care. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 7, 2012
2.5/5 28% Project X (2012) " Say what you want about Project X (and people have), but there's a decent idea behind it. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 4, 2012
2.5/5 24% Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 1 (2011) " While venturing into uncharted body horror territory, Breaking Dawn - Part 1 will do what the previous three instalments have: give the fans something to Rob-sess over and give the haters something to hate." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 3, 2012
2.5/5 84% Beginners (2011) " While some of the cute touches work, the movie's kookyness is ultimately cold and distancing, ensuring that the characters never feel real enough for us to care about them." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 3, 2012
3/5 78% The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel (2012) " The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel could do deemed The Expendables of mature, well-regarded British screen actors. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 3, 2012
2/5 42% Journey 2: The Mysterious Island (2012) " As silly and childish as you might expect, but Johnson ensures that it's watchable through presence and charm alone." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 2, 2012
3/5 39% Speed Racer (2008) " The propulsive car-fu provides an exhilarating wow-factor." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Nov 2, 2012
3/5 44% J. Edgar (2011) " While it's often sluggish as the narrative ping-pongs back and forth through the years in low-key, de-saturated fashion, Hoover makes for such a fascinating subject matter that Eastwood's bio-drama can't help but prove compelling in sporadic bursts." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 30, 2012
3.5/5 96% Undefeated (2012) " one or two scenes feel like they're been manipulated for maximum tear-jerkery (see the surprise, last-minute scholarship), but Coach Courtney is a very watchable central figure." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 29, 2012
4.5/5 91% Star Trek II - The Wrath of Khan (1982) " Infusing more humanity and character work in the first ten minutes than TMP managed in its entire duration, The Wrath Of Khan is a satisfying improvement in almost every respect." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 28, 2012
3.5/5 92% The Sapphires (2013) " While predictable and fluffy, The Sapphires balances foot-tapping soul classics, acerbic Aussie insults and uncomplicated drama to crowd-pleasing effect." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 28, 2012
5/5 92% Skyfall (2012) " Skyfall not only gets things back on track, but delivers what is arguably the best Bond movie of all time." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 27, 2012
4/5 84% JFK (1991) " Essentially three hours (plus) of Oliver Stone presenting a conspiracy theory to the audience, JFK is ambitious, controversial, fascinating, exhausting, and, perhaps most importantly, convincing. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 25, 2012
2/5 44% Star Trek: The Motion Picture (1979) " Far too much time is spent with the bridge crew staring at special effects in awe." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 24, 2012
4/5 82% De rouille et d'os (Rust and Bone) (2012) " Yes, there's liberal amounts of bare-knuckle fighting and naked nookie, but this is primarily a soulful relationship drama which is gentle, powerful and, on occasion, genuinely shattering. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 24, 2012
3/5 20% Chernobyl Diaries (2012) " While it won't win any prizes for originality, Chernobyl Diaries is still a relatively effective horror experience and certainly not deserving of some of the one-star reviews being afforded its way." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 23, 2012
4/5 96% Argo (2012) " It not only confirms Affleck as one of the few A-listers to have made a credible transition to behind the camera, but that he's one of the most exciting mainstream directors around, full stop." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 23, 2012
3.5/5 83% Your Sister's Sister (2012) " Your Sister's Sister is somewhat slight and familiar, but it still manages to offer some reasonably insightful material on love and sibling relationships. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 22, 2012
4.5/5 91% There Will Be Blood (2007) " Challenging and far from an easy watch, even those who do respond might take a couple of viewings to fully realise just how good it is, but there's little doubt that it's a modern masterpiece." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 19, 2012
3/5 49% The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (2010) " it'll still appeal more to teen girls and the Twi-hard, Robsessed fanbase than boyfriends who've been forced to watch by their other halves, but thankfully there's less mopey melodrama." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 19, 2012
3/5 79% Punch-Drunk Love (2002) " There's certainly no questioning the technical ability on show, but unfortunately the end result is often more impressive than it is involving. " — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 17, 2012
4/5 86% Beasts of the Southern Wild (2012) " Part social realism drama, part magical fairytale, part eco-themed cautionary tale, Beasts Of The Southern Wild is arguably three beautiful films rolled into one." — Flix Capacitor
Posted Oct 16, 2012
Showing 51 - 100 of 171
  • Sort by Rating:

    Sort results by this critic's rating. This option is only available for critics with a rating system (4 star, letter grade, 1-10, etc.)

  • Sort by T-meter:

    Sort results by the Tomatometer (percentage of critics recommending a certain movie)

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile