It's hard to objectively rate an episode like 1029. It is at once well-executed and cynically transparent, a sort of necessary evil that is far better than it has any right to be but also too awkward to fit into the continuity of the current arc.
There's nothing particularly egregious about the content of the episode itself. It is a flashback episode where we spend time with young Luffy first meeting Shanks and his daughter Uta. Uta is roughly Luffy's age and they spend time running around and playing together, competing with one another, and learning about each other. Uta wanted to be a star, and the framing device at the beginning of the episode shows us that she does indeed become a worldwide talent in the present day. The episode is well-animated, with plenty of engaging visuals that operate on the sort of dreamy-weamy logic of music videos. Young Luffy even fights a monkey at one point and shares fruit with him! It's fun for the whole family.
That said, this is a straight-up half-hour commercial for One Piece: Film Red, and it's impossible to shake the sense of disruption the entire episode brings. That's… fine, I get it, Toei wants to cross-promote and I don't have any qualms about it per se. I'm sure the crew put in a ton of effort into the film and so they'd want to put in that extra bit of impetus for folks to go see the movie. Not to mention, it's a good-looking episode! The team did not phone it in one bit.
But… it's hard not to feel a huge letdown that we're pumping the brakes on Wano (already an incredibly long arc) to do this for a week. That only further underscores the weirdness of Uta as a character. Don't get me wrong, she has a terrific design, a well-realized motivation, and I don't have any issue with “Shanks had a kid we don't know about.”
The problem is that this entire idea of her having been good friends with Luffy during such a pivotal time in his life seems to be both too important and not important enough all at once. In other words, Uta currently feels detached from the narrative—she essentially is one of the first age-appropriate friends Luffy ever had, and the daughter of his mentor, but Uta doesn't add much to Luffy's story or experience or what we know about him (and how could she, with only 30 minutes of screentime as of now? Perhaps the film expands on this) other than to explain her motivation.
The whole experience fell flat for me, despite its merits.
Trigun Stampede, Vinland Saga Season 2, Tomo-chan Is a Girl!, Don't Toy With Me, Miss Nagatoro 2nd Attack, NieR:Automata Ver1.1a, more― Crunchyroll announced on Wednesday that it is streaming the following anime (dub languages streaming at later date in parentheses) for the winter 2023 season: December 23 Lee's Detective Agency January 4 Tomo-chan Is a Girl! (English, German, French, Russian) Bungo ...
Novel's 32nd, 33rd volumes to release in spring, winter 2023― Advertising in Miya Kazuki's 31st Ascendance of a Bookworm (Honzuki no Gekokujō - Shisho ni Naru Tame niwa Shudan o Erandeiramasen) "biblia fantasy" novel volume (pictured right) announced on December 10 that the story is approaching its conclusion in 2023. The 32nd volume will ship next spring, and the 33rd volume is scheduled for next w...
Production I.G produces anime, Studio Khara handles kaiju designs― The official website for the anime of Naoya Matsumoto's Kaiju No. 8 manga revealed on Friday a teaser promotional video, visual, animation studios, and 2024 premiere. Production I.G (Ghost in the Shell) is handling animation production, and Studio Khara (Rebuild of Evangelion) is in charge of kaiju designs and artworks. Matsumoto lau...
Yū Serizawa, Karin Nanami star in series at Platinum Vision― GL Bunko announced on Tuesday that Inori's I'm in Love with the Villainess (Watashi no Oshi wa Akuyaku Reijō) light novel series is inspiring a television anime adaptation that will premiere in 2023. Hideaki Oba (Love of Kill) is directing the anime at Platinum Vision. Ayumu Hisao (Love of Kill, Devils' Line) is both writing and overseeing...
Ayumu Murase, Natsumi Fujiwara, Maaya Uchida, Kaede Hondo star in baking isekai anime― The official website for the television anime of Nozomu Koryu's Sweet Reincarnation (Okashi na Tensei: Saikyō Patishie Isekai Kōrin) light novels unveiled a new teaser promotional video and teaser visual for the anime on Thursday. The teaser reveals the anime's cast, staff, and July 2023 premiere date. The cast in...
This sports anime changes up the usual shōnen formula by casting a bunch of self-centered players to see who can rise to the top as the ultimate striker. Is there anyone left to root for when all your characters are egoists?― This sports anime changes up the usual shōnen formula by casting a bunch of self-centered players to see who can rise to the top as the ultimate striker. Is there anyone left ...
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stone Ocean is Hirohiko Araki's magnum opus, the culmination of a journey spanning over 100 years and six generations for its characters and a decade for anime viewers.― Forgive me if I start to edge into the sentimental at some point during this review. Jojo's Bizarre Adventure: Stone Ocean is Hirohiko Araki's magnum opus, the culmination of a journey spanning over 100 yea...
Dabi finally revealed his long-orchestrated plan to take down the hero-worshipping society in My Hero Academia! How will the #1 Hero bounce back when his past is on full display?― Dabi's Long-Awaited Reveal is Here Dabi finally revealed his long-orchestrated plan to take down the hero-worshipping society in My Hero Academia! How will the #1 Hero bounce back when his past is on full display? Plus, t...
Kawaguchi's understanding of the original fairy tales adds a novel twist to this shonen action series that makes for an exciting read.― You all know the story of Little Red Riding Hood, and you may even know the tale of Peter Stumpp, an early werewolf. Both of those are brought together here in this title from one of Kohei Horikoshi's (of My Hero Academia fame) former assistants – The Hunters Guild:...
AJ revisits this romantic comedy classic to see if it still wrings the tears from his eyes years later.― Every anime fan remembers the first time a show spoke to them on a deeply emotional level. For me, that was the 2008 romantic comedy anime Toradora, which I discovered through an AMV I randomly came across all the way back in high school. It was the first anime to make me cry more than once, and ...
Bleach and Akiba Maid War have a strong week and thus bump their way up the cumulative. Find out where your favorites rank this week!― Let's have a look at what ANN readers consider the best (and worst) of the season, based on the polls you can find in our Daily Streaming Reviews and on the Your Score page with the latest simulcasts. Keep in mind that these rankings are based on how people rated in...
The horrors of war and its generational effects take center stage in the third omnibus from horror mangaka Kazuo Umezz.― If there is a theme to this third omnibus volume of Kazuo Umezz's horror manga Orochi, it is that we can't always know everything about someone from the face they present to the world. While both stories in this volume, “Stage” and “Combat,” also deal with sons' relationships with...
The heroines of Evangelion: 3.0+1.0 Thrice Upon a Time—Asuka, Rei, and Mari—have been turned into a set of three figures based on an illustration drawn by general animation director Atsushi Nishigori.― The heroines of Evangelion: 3.0+1.0 Thrice Upon a Time—Asuka, Rei, and Mari—have been turned into a set of three figures based on an illustration drawn by general animation director Atsushi Nishigori...
This "girls join an ailing club" anime has stayed mostly under the radar, but its stellar animation and humorous character writing is reason enough to move it off your backlog.― This "girls join an ailing club" anime has stayed mostly under the radar, but its stellar animation and humorous character writing is reason enough to move it off your backlog. This series is streaming on Crunchyroll Discla...
Blitz appears to be a sports manga with a focus on chess, but it fails to sell game newbies to the strategy behind the game.― Blitz is an interesting manga. It is very much in the vein of a typical sports manga, particularly school-based sports manga. You've got a young competitor entering a brand-new world where he must learn the rules of the game and face ever tougher challengers as he grows in sk...
Seasoned musician R.O.N discusses his music writing approach and how an international background helped diversify his compositions.― I first came across the artist Stereo Dive Foundation through their performance of “Daisy,” the ending song for the Kyoto Animation anime Beyond the Boundary. I had no idea at the time that this would become one of the first songs written by a seasoned solo artist perf...